TaxSavvy

Tax planning

F&O and intraday as business income, with tax audit check, Sec 43(5) and 44AB (now 63)

  • Profits and losses from F&O are non-speculative business income and intraday equity is speculative business income, so they go in ITR-3, not under capital gains.
  • Deadline: AY 2026-27: ITR-3 non-audit by 31 August 2026; tax audit report by 30 September 2026; audit-case ITR by 31 October 2026 (reported dates). Loss carry forward needs a return by the due date.
  • Done in 3 working days after broker statements for non-audit; audit cases need the books first
  • Prepared by your Savvy, checked by a CA
  1. Broker tax P&L
  2. Did you trade intraday equity
  3. Download tax P&L and trade-wise turnover from each broker
  4. Turnover and audit decision note
The law and the stepsPay and start · QuoteYearly, + 18% GST

Answer in brief

Profits and losses from F&O are non-speculative business income and intraday equity is speculative business income, so they go in ITR-3, not under capital gains. We compute turnover the ICAI way, check if a tax audit applies, prepare the P&L and balance sheet in the return, and carry forward losses so you can use them later.

Every paid answer is checked by a CA. Free AI answers are labelled until a CA verifies them.

From the official sources

What the law says, and what trips people up

From the official portal's manuals and FAQs, with the source for each point.

The law

  • Income-tax Act 1961, Sec 43(5)

    A contract settled without delivery is speculative, except eligible derivative transactions on a recognised stock exchange (and eligible commodity derivatives); intraday equity remains speculativeSource

  • Income-tax Act 1961, Sec 73 (now Sec 113)

    Speculation loss is set off only against speculation profit and carried forward for at most 4 assessment yearsSource

  • Income-tax Act 1961, Sec 72 and 80 (now Sec 112 and 121)

    Non-speculative business loss carried forward up to 8 years against business income, only if the return is filed in time under Sec 263 (old Sec 139(3))Source

  • Income-tax Act 1961, Sec 44AB (now Sec 63)

    Tax audit if business turnover exceeds ₹1 crore, raised to ₹10 crore where cash receipts and cash payments are each not over 5%; also where a person who opted for Sec 58 (old Sec 44AD) declares lower profit within the 5-year lock-in and income exceeds the basic exemption limitSource

  • ICAI Guidance Note on Tax Audit under Sec 63 (old Sec 44AB; Revised 2023), para 5.10(b)

    Derivatives turnover = total of favourable and unfavourable differences on squared-off trades; premium on options sold included unless already in net profit; reverse trade differences includedSource

  • Income-tax Act 2025, Sec 63 and Sec 263

    From tax year 2026-27 tax audit moves to Sec 63 and return filing to Sec 263Source

  • Income-tax Act 2025, Sec 536(2)(m) and (n)

    F&O and speculation losses from years before 1 April 2026 keep their character and are carried forward under the 2025 ActSource

  • Government fee

    No government fee. Business income is taxed at slab rates. Source: https://www.incometax.gov.in/iec/foportal/help/individual/return-applicable-1

  • Late fee or penalty

    Late return: Sec 428 (old Sec 234F) fee up to ₹5,000 and loss of carry forward for business and speculation losses. Sources: https://www.incometaxindia.gov.in/w/section-234f and https://www.incometaxindia.gov.in/w/section-80-7 . Late tax audit report from tax year 2026-27: reported penalty of ₹75,000 (delay up to 1 month) or ₹1.5 lakh. Source: https://www.businesstoday.in/amp/personal-finance/tax/story/itr-due-dates-revised-returns-and-audit-penalties-3-big-tax-changes-from-ay-2026-27-537295-2026-06-17

On the portal

  1. e-File > Income Tax Returns > File Income Tax Return > AY 2026-27 > ITR-3
  2. Select nature of business codes for trading; declare whether accounts are audited
  3. Fill Part A P&L and balance sheet (or 'no account case' items where allowed)
  4. Schedule BP: show speculative income separately from non-speculative F&O income
  5. Schedule CG and 112A for delivery sales; CYLA, BFLA and CFL for losses
  6. If audited, quote the audit report acknowledgement and date; pay and e-verify

What trips people up

  • F&O loss shown under capital gains in ITR-2

    F&O on a recognised exchange is non-speculative business; file ITR-3Source

  • Turnover taken as contract value, wrongly triggering audit

    Use the ICAI method: absolute favourable and unfavourable differences plus option premium soldSource

  • Belief that any F&O loss forces an audit

    A loss alone does not; audit follows turnover limits or the 44AD lock-in ruleSource

  • Scrip-wise turnover from broker differs from trade-wise turnover

    Use trade-wise turnover where available; it is the more defensible methodSource

  • Trader assumes 31 July applies to ITR-3

    For AY 2026-27 non-audit ITR-3 is reported due on 31 August 2026Source

People ask

Is intraday taxed like F&O?

No. Intraday equity is speculative business; F&O on a recognised exchange is non-speculative business.Source

How long can I carry forward losses?

Speculation loss 4 years against speculation income; F&O loss 8 years against business income, if filed on time.Source

Do I need an audit with ₹40 lakh turnover and a loss?

Not because of the loss. Check whether you used 44AD in the last 5 years and whether your income is above the basic exemption limit.Source

Which ITR?

ITR-3 for business income without presumptive taxation; ITR-4 only for presumptive income and with its exclusions.Source

IDFD

How we solve it: 4 steps

Every line tracked live.

Step 1 of 4 · What we need from you

Tap each one you already have

Ready0 / 7
  • Broker tax P&L, all segments
  • Trade-wise turnover report
  • Contract notes and charges sheet
  • Bank and broker ledger statement
  • Last 5 years' ITRs (Sec 58 (old 44AD) use)
  • Brought forward F&O and speculation lossesOptional
  • Trading-related expenses (internet, advisory, software)Optional

Connect now

A Savvy replies in minutes.

Fixed price before you pay. Your Savvy is paid only after you accept the work.

Connect nowPay and start: Quote

Answers on this topic

Ask any money problem

Pay and start

Quote

+ 18% GST

Yearly. Delivered in 3 working days after broker statements for non-audit; audit cases need the books first. Due: AY 2026-27: ITR-3 non-audit by 31 August 2026; tax audit report by 30 September 2026; audit-case ITR by 31 October 2026 (reported dates). Loss carry forward needs a return by the due date.

This one is quoted after your Savvy has a quick look. Start from the main plan above.

  • Every paid answer checked by a CA
  • Fixed price before you pay
  • Track every step live
  • Updates on WhatsApp and in your dashboard