Q: TDS on Property Purchase: Section 393(1) (old 194IA)

Most property buyers do not know they are legally required to deduct 1% TDS from the payment to the seller and file Form 141 (old Form 26QB). This is one of the most commonly missed TDS obligations in India. Who files Form 141 (old Form 26QB): The BUYER. Not the seller, not the builder, not the bank. Even if you take a home loan, you (the buyer) must deduct 1% and file Form 141 (old Form 26QB). Multiple sellers: If husband and wife both sell jointly, separate Form 141 (old Form 26QB) for each seller. Each Form 141 (old Form 26QB) is for their respective share (typically 50% each). Two 26QBs, each at 0.5% of total = 1% total. Multiple payments: If you pay ₹10L booking, ₹40L on registration, ₹30L balance, file a separate Form 141 (old Form 26QB) for EACH payment within 30 days of that payment. Threshold ₹50L is TOTAL, not per payment. NRI seller: Section 393, Income-tax Act 2025 (old Sec 195) applies instead of Sec 393(1) Table Sl. No. 3(i) (old Sec 194IA). TDS rate is 20-30% (LTCG or STCG rate). CA essential for NRI seller transactions. Form 141 (old Form 26QB) filing: incometax.gov.in → e-Pay Tax → TDS on Property (Form 141, old Form 26QB). Fill buyer PAN, seller PAN, property address, consideration, payment date. Pay online. Form 132 (old Form 16B) downloadable from TRACES portal 5-7 days later.

Q: NRI Property Sale: TDS 20 to 30% by Buyer (Section 393, old 195)

When an NRI sells property in India, the buyer must deduct TDS at 20% (LTCG rate) or 30% (STCG rate) on the ENTIRE sale consideration, not just the gain. This is the most commonly mishandled NRI transaction. A ₹1Cr property sale → buyer must deduct ₹20L in TDS. NRI then claims refund after filing ITR. The TDS problem: Section 393, Income-tax Act 2025 (old Sec 195) requires TDS on the ENTIRE consideration (not just gain). ₹1Cr property → buyer must deduct 20% = ₹20L TDS from payment to NRI seller. NRI receives ₹80L. NRI then files ITR, computes actual LTCG (say ₹30L), tax on LTCG ₹3.75L (12.5%), claims refund of ₹20L − ₹3.75L = ₹16.25L. Refund takes 6-12 months. Lower TDS certificate, the solution: NRI seller applies to Assessing Officer (under Sec 393 (old Sec 195(2)) or Sec 248) for a certificate allowing lower TDS. Certificate specifies TDS only on the actual capital gains portion, not full consideration. This dramatically reduces upfront TDS. Process takes 30-60 days. NRI seller should apply well before property transaction. DTAA benefit: Many DTAA (India-USA, India-UK, India-UAE etc.) allow lower TDS rates or provide that capital gains from immovable property are taxed only in the country where property is situated (India).

Q: Section 78 (old 50C), Stamp Duty Value vs Sale Price: The Deemed Consideration Trap

One of the most punishing provisions in property taxation. If you sell a property below its circle rate (stamp duty valuation), the government treats the HIGHER circle rate as your actual sale price for capital gains computation. You pay tax on money you never received. Both buyer and seller are caught. Real-world example of the double hit: Actual deal: Seller sells flat for ₹75L. Circle rate says ₹1Cr. Difference: ₹25L (25% above actual). SELLER side: LTCG computed on ₹1Cr (not ₹75L). Seller pays extra tax on ₹25L they never received. Say LTCG rate 12.5%: ₹3.125L extra tax on phantom income. BUYER side: Bought at ₹75L but SDV says ₹1Cr. Difference ₹25L > ₹50,000 AND > 10% → Sec 92(2)(m), Income-tax Act 2025 (old Sec 56(2)(x)) → ₹25L taxed as other income for buyer at slab rate. At 30%: ₹7.5L tax for buyer on money they "saved.". The 10% safe harbour, critical planning tool: If circle rate is ₹1Cr and actual deal is ₹92L (8% below circle rate): 92/100 = 92%. Difference = 8% < 10%. Sec 78 (old Sec 50C) does not apply. No deemed consideration for seller. No Sec 92(2)(m) (old Sec 56(2)(x)) for buyer. This 10% band is your negotiation safe zone. Deals within 10% of circle rate are clean.

Question 1

TDS on Property Purchase: Section 393(1) (old 194IA), Form 141 (old Form 26QB)

Accepted Answer

When you buy any property valued above ₹50L, you must deduct 1% TDS from the payment to the seller and deposit it with the government. This is not optional. The buyer is responsible, not the seller. Non-compliance: buyer becomes assessee in default with 1.5%/month interest and penalty equal to TDS. Most property buyers discover this obligation only after receiving a notice. How Sec 393(1) Table Sl. No. 3(i), Income-tax Act 2025 (old Sec 194IA) works step by step: Buyer pays token money ₹5L (Day 1). TDS: 1% of ₹5L = ₹5,000. Pay ₹4,95,000 to seller. Deposit ₹5,000 TDS to government. File Form 141 (old Form 26QB) within 30 days. Next milestone payment ₹20L (Day 60). TDS: ₹20,000. Same process. At registration: balance payment ₹25L. TDS: ₹25,000. Same process. Total TDS for ₹50L property: ₹50,000 (1%). Each payment requires separate Form 141 (old Form 26QB). What is included in "consideration": Base property price. Parking charges (if mentioned in agreement). Maintenance deposit (if part of agreement consideration). Club/amenity charges in agreement. All components mentioned in agreement = total consideration. If total consideration (all components) ≥ ₹50L: TDS applies on the full amount. If total consideration < ₹50L: no TDS even if individual apartment price seems high.

Question 2

TDS on Property Purchase: Section 393(1) (old 194IA)

Accepted Answer

Most property buyers do not know they are legally required to deduct 1% TDS from the payment to the seller and file Form 141 (old Form 26QB). This is one of the most commonly missed TDS obligations in India. Who files Form 141 (old Form 26QB): The BUYER. Not the seller, not the builder, not the bank. Even if you take a home loan, you (the buyer) must deduct 1% and file Form 141 (old Form 26QB). Multiple sellers: If husband and wife both sell jointly, separate Form 141 (old Form 26QB) for each seller. Each Form 141 (old Form 26QB) is for their respective share (typically 50% each). Two 26QBs, each at 0.5% of total = 1% total. Multiple payments: If you pay ₹10L booking, ₹40L on registration, ₹30L balance, file a separate Form 141 (old Form 26QB) for EACH payment within 30 days of that payment. Threshold ₹50L is TOTAL, not per payment. NRI seller: Section 393, Income-tax Act 2025 (old Sec 195) applies instead of Sec 393(1) Table Sl. No. 3(i) (old Sec 194IA). TDS rate is 20-30% (LTCG or STCG rate). CA essential for NRI seller transactions. Form 141 (old Form 26QB) filing: incometax.gov.in → e-Pay Tax → TDS on Property (Form 141, old Form 26QB). Fill buyer PAN, seller PAN, property address, consideration, payment date. Pay online. Form 132 (old Form 16B) downloadable from TRACES portal 5-7 days later.

Question 3

NRI Property Sale: TDS 20 to 30% by Buyer (Section 393, old 195)

Accepted Answer

When an NRI sells property in India, the buyer must deduct TDS at 20% (LTCG rate) or 30% (STCG rate) on the ENTIRE sale consideration, not just the gain. This is the most commonly mishandled NRI transaction. A ₹1Cr property sale → buyer must deduct ₹20L in TDS. NRI then claims refund after filing ITR. The TDS problem: Section 393, Income-tax Act 2025 (old Sec 195) requires TDS on the ENTIRE consideration (not just gain). ₹1Cr property → buyer must deduct 20% = ₹20L TDS from payment to NRI seller. NRI receives ₹80L. NRI then files ITR, computes actual LTCG (say ₹30L), tax on LTCG ₹3.75L (12.5%), claims refund of ₹20L − ₹3.75L = ₹16.25L. Refund takes 6-12 months. Lower TDS certificate, the solution: NRI seller applies to Assessing Officer (under Sec 393 (old Sec 195(2)) or Sec 248) for a certificate allowing lower TDS. Certificate specifies TDS only on the actual capital gains portion, not full consideration. This dramatically reduces upfront TDS. Process takes 30-60 days. NRI seller should apply well before property transaction. DTAA benefit: Many DTAA (India-USA, India-UK, India-UAE etc.) allow lower TDS rates or provide that capital gains from immovable property are taxed only in the country where property is situated (India).

Question 4

Section 78 (old 50C), Stamp Duty Value vs Sale Price: The Deemed Consideration Trap

Accepted Answer

One of the most punishing provisions in property taxation. If you sell a property below its circle rate (stamp duty valuation), the government treats the HIGHER circle rate as your actual sale price for capital gains computation. You pay tax on money you never received. Both buyer and seller are caught. Real-world example of the double hit: Actual deal: Seller sells flat for ₹75L. Circle rate says ₹1Cr. Difference: ₹25L (25% above actual). SELLER side: LTCG computed on ₹1Cr (not ₹75L). Seller pays extra tax on ₹25L they never received. Say LTCG rate 12.5%: ₹3.125L extra tax on phantom income. BUYER side: Bought at ₹75L but SDV says ₹1Cr. Difference ₹25L > ₹50,000 AND > 10% → Sec 92(2)(m), Income-tax Act 2025 (old Sec 56(2)(x)) → ₹25L taxed as other income for buyer at slab rate. At 30%: ₹7.5L tax for buyer on money they "saved.". The 10% safe harbour, critical planning tool: If circle rate is ₹1Cr and actual deal is ₹92L (8% below circle rate): 92/100 = 92%. Difference = 8% < 10%. Sec 78 (old Sec 50C) does not apply. No deemed consideration for seller. No Sec 92(2)(m) (old Sec 56(2)(x)) for buyer. This 10% band is your negotiation safe zone. Deals within 10% of circle rate are clean.

Buying property over ₹50 lakh? Deduct 1% TDS right.

How we get it done

Information

Discussion

Forms

Deliverables

See what you get, free

Questions, answered the CA way

Buying property over ₹50 lakh? Deduct 1% TDS right.