PRP

Tolerance for older years: 5% or 10%

Updated . Reviewed by Rishabh Goyal, Chartered Accountant. Every paid answer is checked by a CA. Free AI answers are labelled until a CA verifies them.

Facts

The tolerance under Sec 50C of the Income-tax Act 1961 (now Sec 78) was 5% for AY 2019-20 and AY 2020-21, and 10% from AY 2021-22. For a sale in FY 2018-19 or FY 2019-20, an 8% gap is above the 5% allowed.

Provisions and law

Sec 50C, Income-tax Act 1961 (now Sec 78, Income-tax Act 2025); Sec 50C(2), Income-tax Act 1961 (now Sec 78, Income-tax Act 2025)

Analysis

For a sale in FY 2019-20, 8% below the stamp value crosses the 5% tolerance, so the stamp value can replace your price. Some tribunals have applied the 10% tolerance to earlier years as curative, but this is not settled. You can also ask for a valuation by the Valuation Officer if the market value was lower.

Conclusion

  1. Find the financial year of your sale.
  2. Compare the price gap with the tolerance for that year.
  3. Argue the curative view if relevant, and seek a valuation reference.
  4. Reply on the e-proceedings portal on time.

Assuming 10% for every year is a common mistake in old cases.

Connect now

A Savvy replies in minutes.

Fixed price before you pay. Your Savvy is paid only after you accept the work.

General guidance from TaxSavvy’s library of money processes. Laws change; your Savvy confirms the answer on your exact case before anything is filed.