PRP

Replying to a penalty notice after a stamp value addition

Updated . Reviewed by Rishabh Goyal, Chartered Accountant. Every paid answer is checked by a CA. Free AI answers are labelled until a CA verifies them.

Facts

Penalty for under-reported income is 50% of the tax on it, and 200% where it results from misreporting such as suppressing facts. A deemed addition where the facts were fully disclosed is generally argued as not misreporting.

Provisions and law

Sec 439, Income-tax Act 2025 (old Sec 270A); Sec 471, Income-tax Act 2025 (old Sec 274); Sec 78, Income-tax Act 2025 (old Sec 50C)

Analysis

Show that you reported the sale, the price and the stamp value in your return, and the addition arose only from the deeming rule or a valuation dispute. Point out any request you made for a Valuation Officer reference. If the addition is under appeal, ask that penalty proceedings be kept pending. On ₹10 lakh added at 30% tax, a 50% penalty is about ₹1.5 lakh, so a careful reply matters.

Conclusion

  1. Read the notice and the limb of penalty proposed.
  2. Show your disclosures in the return.
  3. Explain the bona fide valuation dispute.
  4. Ask for proceedings to await the appeal outcome.
  5. Appeal any penalty order within time.

Not replying usually results in penalty being levied.

Connect now

A Savvy replies in minutes.

Fixed price before you pay. Your Savvy is paid only after you accept the work.

General guidance from TaxSavvy’s library of money processes. Laws change; your Savvy confirms the answer on your exact case before anything is filed.