GST

Paying penalty under protest and still appealing

Updated . Reviewed by Rishabh Goyal, Chartered Accountant. Every paid answer is checked by a CA. Free AI answers are labelled until a CA verifies them.

Facts

Paying the penalty to get goods released does not take away the right to appeal. Record in writing that payment is made under protest. Then file the appeal within 3 months of the order.

Provisions and law

Sec 107, CGST Act 2017; Sec 129, CGST Act 2017

Analysis

Paying the penalty to get goods released does not take away the right to appeal under Sec 107. Record in writing that payment is made under protest. If the appeal succeeds, the penalty is refunded. Example: Rs 1.8 lakh paid under protest to release perishable goods; appeal won later; refund claimed.

Conclusion

  1. Write a protest letter at the time of payment.
  2. Keep the payment proof.
  3. File the appeal within time.
  4. Claim refund if successful.

Without a protest letter, the officer may argue you accepted the penalty.

Connect now

A Savvy replies in minutes.

Fixed price before you pay. Your Savvy is paid only after you accept the work.

General guidance from TaxSavvy’s library of money processes. Laws change; your Savvy confirms the answer on your exact case before anything is filed.