Answer

ITR

Using reasonable cause to defend a penalty

Updated . Every paid answer is checked by a CA. Free AI answers are labelled until a CA verifies them.

  1. Facts

    For many penalties, Sec 273B says no penalty if you prove reasonable cause for the failure. For Sec 270A, the defence is mainly through its own exclusions, such as a bona fide explanation with full disclosure. Reliance on a professional can support either argument if it is genuine.

  2. Provisions and law

    • Sec 273B, Income-tax Act 1961No penalty for certain failures if reasonable cause is shown
    • Sec 270A (now Sec 439)Penalty of 50% of tax on under-reported income, or 200% where under-reporting is due to misreporting
  3. Analysis

    Give facts, not just a statement. For example, show that you gave all documents to the accountant, that the error was a wrong schedule entry, and that you paid tax once it was found. An affidavit from the accountant can help. Reasonable cause works better for technical failures, like a late audit report, than for income that was hidden.

  4. Conclusion

    1. Write down the timeline of what happened
    2. Collect proof that full information was given
    3. Get a letter or affidavit from the professional if relevant
    4. Present it in the reply with supporting documents

The 2025 Act number for Sec 273B is not confirmed in our mapping; cite the 1961 section for past years.

A Savvy can do this for you

Penalty notice, Sec 270A / 274 (now 439 / 471)

₹4,999

Get this doneAsk a Savvy on WhatsApp

General guidance from TaxSavvy’s library of money processes. Laws change; your Savvy confirms the answer on your exact case before anything is filed.

People also ask